To follow more of our ramblings and get the insider track on what's going on,
follow us on Twitter: @49thfloor or on Facebook.com/49thfloor

Self praise is no praise

Rate this item
(0 votes)

Further to the blog post the other day about placing testimonials on your web site, due to recent events I wanted to follow this up with a question to you all.

I have recently read the CV of an ex-colleague (whose name shall be kept to myself so as to a. avoid blushes and b. avoid law-suits) which goes into great detail about his strengths - narrowly avoiding the point of toe-curling pretension, but stopping just ahead of the 'ugh' marker. Obviously a CV is the first port of call used by prospective employees to sell themselves to a company, organisation or person enough to warrant a call back or indeed an interview. Whilst I understand the necessity to make yourself sound strong in a multitude of areas and back this up with both real life experience and relevant education/training, this is where a lot of people can come unstuck via an unfortunate lying snowball, which paints the picture of a completely different person than that who actually exists. What can begin as a genuine attempt to add some sheen to your skill-set by either taking full credit for a bit-part role or making the most out of what was in reality either a failure or product of questionable merit, can later turn into an out and out den of lies.

 

 

I have known many designers flesh out the CVs and follow that right up into the interview with a portfolio stuffed to bursting with printed crap lying around the office, or even worse by appropriating what has come through their door that day. This is an unsavoury thought to those of us who tend to play by the rules, but it's never bothered me too much because I have assumed that employers are too concerned about who they employ to allow liars to slip the net. Hopefully this is borne out by the experiences of others, but nonetheless the unscrupulous will still try it.

In the specific CV example I am referring to today the person in question has not lied in this fashion, but has gone on to make a faux pas in my eyes of equal level, if not surpassing it with deft skill. He has quoted his colleagues from a previous employer, essentially offering their reviews of him as a person and his work. As an example (but not a direct quote):

"Geoff Creatus is not only the nicest man I have ever known, but is also the nicest man, the nicest man in the world has ever known. His phallus is biblical in proportion, both on the x and the y planes and boy does he know how to use it. I've never seen a man use his thumb and forefingers with such heavenly dexterity, why if God had an ad agency tasked with selling loaves and fishes to infidels and heathens he would be mad not to employ Geoff Creatus."

Sadly, there is not just one example of this on his CV, but as many as 6. I think everything that was said about testimonials for companies should stand for personally commissioned reviews and that even if you were to have these on file, they shouldn't be splattered over the most business like of documents - the CV. Isn't it the duty of the respective employer to request a reference upon their own steam and therefore guarantee it's neutrality and honesty? Maybe it's just me who thinks like this, but I wanted to put it out there and ask if anyone has gone down this road themselves and if it had a positive outcome.

Last modified on Friday, 22 April 2011 10:45
David Smith

David Smith

Andy and I make up 49th Floor Design and Artworking. yeah, yeah this is great, but more importantly; I own the Mysterious Cities of Gold and Quincy DVD box sets.

Website: www.facebook.com/49thfloor

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.
Basic HTML code is allowed.

Scroll To Top